Mister Pizza Elmwood

Reviews

• Karen L.

  star star star star star 11 June 2026

  A couple of weeks ago I grabbed a couple of slices late night...my expectations for this particular hour were pretty low but I was pleasantly surprised that the slices were hot and extremely fresh!! You just never know when the craving of pizza will arise and Mister Pizza has shown to fill this need at all hours!  
  
  The employees are friendly and very efficient.
  
  More recently, we ordered a specialty pizza and tots. I've never had their spinach and ricotta pizza before but I have to say that it was absolute perfection!!!!! The menu gives you a couple recommended options for this specialty...to add red sauce at your request and the choice of pepperoni or sausage(at no additional charge). We went with the pepperoni   and white base (olive oil and garlic). I might have liked the pepperoni if next time I ordered the red sauce to be added but I just did not prefer the pepperoni with the white based sauce. This pizza was truly fantastic without any meat at all! They have so many specialty pizzas that it will be hard to order the same one twice in a row but this one is def on my favorites list.
  Also tator tots are not a typical side to pizza as far as I'm concerned, but they are now a necessity. So crispy crunchy even when you get home!
  
  *also to note...reheating the slices in the oven the next day is equally as enjoyable as day 1*

• Jessica W.

  star star star star_border star_border 11 June 2026

  I was looking for an easy delivery option that would be OK for both gluten eaters and gluten-free folk, and Mister Pizza fit the bill. I scheduled the delivery in advance on Grubhub, and the delivery was right on time, which I appreciate especially when feeding guests.
  
  We got a large eggplant pizza (regular crust) and a small gluten-free cheese pizza. I like fairly thin crusts, but wasn't a big fan of Mister Pizza's. The end crusts were too thin, and tough and crispy. I hate wasting food, but some of the crust went uneaten by the group. The cheese and sauce were fine. As for the gluten-free pizza, I tried some of it and could tell it wasn't regular pizza, but it seemed pretty good for gluten-free pizza. The gluten-free person in our party was satisfied.
  
  I'll stick to other pizza places if ordering for people who can all eat gluten, but would go for Mister Pizza again if I needed to accommodate gluten-free eaters.

• Karen Z.

  star star star star star 4 June 2026

  My wife and I got pizza for Valentine's Day!!She has gluten issues and got the gluten free.SHE WAS SO HAPPY.She said it was the best crust she ever had.I can't report about cross contamination but WOW,great crust
  Update,something is going on with Mr Pizza.Have been ordering from them for going on 20 years now and never had a delivery problem....until today.One and a half hour for a less than mile delivery????Might just start calling Just Pizza now.Plus of course the pizza was cold!!!! Hoping this is a one off,the owner did die a while ago.

• Thomas M.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 1 June 2026

  I buy into the saying "there's no such thing as bad pizza. Even bad pizza is still good".  With that being said this is probably the worst pizza i've had in the Buffalo area.  So I would say this Mister Pizza compares to something you would get from an average chain pizza place like Dominos or Papa Johns.  The crust is a little thinner than a typical "Buffalo style" pizza with the semisweet sauce.  I usually prefer a thinner crust but the pizza I've had from Mister Pizza is not very crisp and even a little tough/chewy.  I've had their pizza a handful of times and I regret it every time.  There are just better places in the surrounding area to get pizza.

• Dennis C.

  star star star star star 17 May 2026

  As soon as I'm done with one of Mister Pizza's pizzas, I'm already thinking of the next.  They are so generous with toppings!  I always get the vegetarian and it's loaded, plus, you can request for hot peppers - no extra charge!  No one else does that.
  
  Every slice is even with the toppings, which is so rare. Always cooked to perfection.  Buffalo has tons of great pizza joints, but it always is Mister Pizza for me.